Barbecuing and smoking go hand in hand like love and marriage. However, choosing and buying the very best charcoal smoker is not always so easy. After all, meat cooked on a BBQ is one thing but when it comes to smoking your meat it is essential that you buy and use the best charcoal smoker you can.
Best Charcoal Smoker 2019
Yes, there is the option of buying a modern electric smoker but to get a truly authentic, tender, and perfectly textured meat, full of flavor and taste, you really need to use a charcoal smoker. People can be forgiven for thinking all charcoal smokers are the same but they vary greatly in build quality, heat and smoke retention, and other factors. Hopefully, our picks of the best charcoal smokers will help you chose the very best charcoal smoker for your needs.
Primo Grills are actually best on Japanese style Kamado ovens. Put simply this fact will allow you to barbecue like you would never imagine possible. This is largely down to the fact Primo Grills are manufactured with a ceramic interior. This act as one of the best ever insulators which keeps in both smoke and heat. This obviously makes the Primo Ceramic Charcoal Smoker Grill very economical as it requires less charcoal than most of the best charcoal grills on the market.
The Primo Ceramic Charcoal Smoker Grill has ample cooking space offering an impressive 400 square inches.
The oval design of the Primo Ceramic Charcoal Smoker Grill gives the cook many options that a regular smoker does not. One such option is it enables you to cook indirectly or directly. In simple terms this means if you are able to grill and smoke at the same time.
Yes, the Primo Ceramic Charcoal Smoker Grill is an expensive smoker. In fact it goes without saying that the Primo Ceramic Charcoal Smoker Grill is certainly the most expensive of our picks of best charcoal smokers. It really is worth that money. The Primo Ceramic Charcoal Smoker Grill is so economical to run and retains heat so well that many people who have used and reviewed the Primo Ceramic Charcoal Smoker Grill claim to have cooked for an entire day using only one lump of charcoal.
The bottom line is that the Primo Ceramic Charcoal Smoker Grill really is the best charcoal smoker that money can buy. The only down side we can give is the price and the fact that we would have liked to have seen a larger cooking area.
|Excellent Hear Retention||Heavy So Not Easy To Move|
|Offers Huge Range Of Cooking Styles|
|Cooks Food Superbly|
|Very Economical To Run|
Marketed as a compact vertical smoker the Weber 731001 Smokey is ideal for those with limited space. Despite its compact vertical design it still boasts a cooking surface of 726 square inches split between two nickel plated racks. This makes it large enough to cook two whole turkey’s at a time.
Manufactured from porcelain enamelled steel means that the Weber 731001 Smokey is not only strong it is also likely to stand the test of time. Its excellent construction and design also features heat-resistant nylon handles so you have little fear of burning yourself.
We particularly like that the Weber 731001 Smokey features a wide opening front door. This means adding extra charcoal and easy access to your meat is as easy as can be.
A built-in thermometer makes easy work of keeping a close eye on the temperature of this charcoal smoker while a specially designed water pan means mess and clean up is limited. The individual vents located on the bowl and lid make controlling the smoke and heat of the Weber 731001 Smokey particularly easy.
If you are in the market for the best charcoal smoker under 400 dollars and good quality is important to you then you should seriously consider the Weber 731001 Smokey.
|Well Built Overall||Door Could Be Stronger|
|Provides Great Quality Smoking|
|Easy To Control Heat|
|Wide Opening Door|
Among our picks of best charcoal smokers the Backwoods Chubby 3400 stands out as one of the best portable charcoal smokers available. It is certainly not the cheapest charcoal smoker but it is indeed worth the money.
A specially developed and proven reverse flow, double wall design makes the end results of your cooked food simply fantastic.
Offering enough cooking space to cook around 8 slabs of baby back ribs at once the Backwoods Chubby 3400 ensures there is enough food to go around. The cooking space is split between four separate cooking grates. This of course is good news when you consider that for the ideal smoked food it takes around 6 to 10 hours to get just right.
Fitted with a thermometer to the front of the unit it is easy to keep a close eye on the internal temperature as you cook while the two doors make it easy to add extra charcoal without effecting the temperature in the cooking chamber.
The unit itself is fully insulated for maximum safety and efficiency while the stainless steel cooking chamber makes it ridiculously easy to keep clean. It is also powered coated so you can be assured it will stand the test of time and you will not face issues of paint flaking off.
To make keeping the Backwoods Chubby 3400 clean it comes with a removable stainless steel water pan which minimises mess whilst cooking.
If portability, top quality construction, and durability is important to you then look no further than the Backwoods Chubby 3400 as one of the best charcoal smokers out there.
The Barrel House Cooker 18C is a superbly engineered, easy to use barrel shaped charcoal smoker that claims to cook food a stunning 40% quicker than traditional smokers.
The barrel design and shape helps to trap in drippings from the meat by vaporising them. This is achievable since the meat hangs directly over the coals.
Te cooking area provided by the Barrel House Cooker 18C is enough to cook at least 10 racks of ribs, 4 whole chickens, or 2 turkeys at once. Alternatively the cleverly designed 18 inch grilling area can accommodate up to 10 large hamburgers.
Once set up the Barrel House Cooker 18C is easy to cook with and maintain. It takes as little as 15 minutes to set things up and once set up the Barrel House Cooker 18C has the ability to maintain the same temperature for up to six hours at a time. Cooking with the Barrel House Cooker 18C really could not be any easier.
A removable base makes keeping mess and cleaning the Barrel House Cooker 18C an absolute breeze.
Simplicity of use combined with top quality construction and excellent cooking abilities really does make the Barrel House Cooker 18C one of the best charcoal smokers out there.
|Authentic Cooking Results||Adding Charcoal Is Difficult|
|Easy To Use|
|Excellent Build Quality|
|Fast Cooking Time|
The Dyna-Glo DG01176 is considered one of the best charcoal smokers and also happens to be what is known as an offset smoker. This means rather than placing the charcoal directly under the cooking grates it is placed in a firebox that is attached to the side. This is particularly beneficial when adding extra charcoal since heat is not lost from the main cooking chamber.
What we really love about the Dyna-Glo DG01176 is the fact it is among the best charcoal smokers for people on a budget.
Divided between 6 separate cooking grates the Dyna-Glo DG01176 offers up a huge 784 square inches of cooking space. It is capable of smoking up to 100 lbs of food at any single time. This is more than enough for even the largest of occasions.
As many people who are familiar with charcoal barbecues will know, igniting the coals can be somewhat bothersome. This problem is taken care of quite nicely with the Dyna-Glo DG01176 as it features a clever ignition system which is both quick and reliable.
The main cooking chamber has a thermometer fitted to the front for monitoring of temperature throughout your cook. It also has an easy to operate smoke stack / vent on the roof which is used to control the heat and smoke flow.
The firebox is made from heavy gauge porcelain enamelled steel while the main cooking chamber is manufactured from heavy duty cast iron capable of withstanding temperatures as high as 15,000 BTU. The materials used in the construction of the Dyna-Glo DG01176 are also powder coated which adds durability and means you do not need worry about flaking paint.
If we were to pick fault with the Dyna-Glo DG01176 we would say that the materials used to construct it could be that little bit thicker. The reason we say this is because this smoker does struggle to keep in the heat and smoke. With that said, for the great price, we really struggle to hold that against it. If you are on a tight budget or if you wish to buy an offset smoker then the Dyna-Glo DG01176 really could be the best charcoal smoker for your needs.
|Easy To Use||Suffers Heat Loss|
|Offset Smoker Is Easy To Clean|
|Good Sized Cooking Space|
Despite its cheap price point the Masterbuild 20060416 is still remarkable well manufactured and feels generally sturdy.
A total of 395 square inches of cooking space divided between two enamel coated cooking grates offers plenty of space to cook for a family BBQ.
A lift off lid makes adding food easy while a front door access panel makes it just as easy to add extra charcoal. The lid even features a handy thermometer so you can keep a close eye on the temperature as your food cooks.
A porcelain coated water bowl and charcoal pan keeps mess to a minimum and makes cleaning the Masterbuild 20060416 particularly easy.
While the lack of a flue can make controlling the temperature a little more difficult than some charcoal smokers and the small nature of the front access panel can make tending the charcoal awkward, there really is not to much to complain about with the Masterbuild 20060416.
Grilling and smoking does not get much simpler than this. The bottom line is if you are looking for a cheap smoker that is so portable you could use it for a tailgate party then the Masterbuild 20060416 is worth considering as the best charcoal grill to suit your needs.
|Highly Portable||Charcoal Difficult To Tend|
|Very Easy To Use|
If you are looking for a charcoal smoker that is portable enough to take on camping trips or to a friends house then the Old Smokey #22 charcoal grill could certainly be the best charcoal grill for your needs.
Its compact, lightweight, and simple design makes it ideal for transporting pretty much anywhere. With a height of 27 inches and a diameter of 22 inches you will struggle to find a more portable charcoal smoker.
Even though the Old Smokey #22 charcoal grill is compact and lightweight in design it still manages to offer a very respectable 333 square inches of cooking space. Not only that, since it is manufactured from aluminised steel it is still remarkable robust and strong.
You really will struggle to find a more simple and easy to use charcoal smoker than the Old Smokey #22. Operating this charcoal smoker is as simple as igniting your charcoal and controlling the temperature via the two vents. Other than that, it is a simple case of keeping a close eye on your meat as it cooks. What could be more simple?
If it is portability combined with simplicity that you desire then the Old Smokey #22 is certainly the best charcoal grill for you. It is even sold at a very reasonable price. What is not to love?
|Great Price||Low Ground Clearance Without Legs|
|Simple To Use|
The Dyna-Glo Signature Series DGSS1382VCS-D is our second pick of best charcoal smokers that also happens to be an offset smoker. As we have already discussed an offset smoke does not have the coals directly under your cooking area but located in special firebox attached to the side of the unit.
Featuring a compact horizontal design the Dyna-Glo Signature Series DGSS1382VCS-D maximises cooking space in a compact space. Spread between six cooking grates the Dyna-Glo Signature Series DGSS1382VCS-D offers a huge 1382 square inches off cooking space. That makes the Dyna-Glo Signature Series DGSS1382VCS-D cable of offering one of the largest cooking areas among our picks of best charcoal smokers.
Manufactured from heavy-gauge high quality steel the Dyna-Glo Signature Series DGSS1382VCS-D is extremely well built and will last the test of time.
The lid and covers featured on the Dyna-Glo Signature Series DGSS1382VCS-D feature a special cool touch spring lid design. This means you need not fear burning yourself while having excellent access to your food as it cooks.
It is nice to see a stainless steel temperature gauge on the Dyna-Glo Signature Series DGSS1382VCS-D which is simply perfect for monitoring the temperature of the Dyna-Glo Signature Series DGSS1382VCS-D while it cooks your food.
What we really love about this pick of best charcoal smoker is the fact that it features oversized wheels which makes this charcoal smoker easy to move and highly portable around your yard or garden.
|Offset Smoker||Temperature Control Could Be Better|
|Strong Durable Build|
|Large Cooking Space|
If you happen to be looking for not only the best charcoal smoker but also a fantastic grill then the Dyna-Glo DGN576DNC-D may well be of interest to you. Not only does the Dyna-Glo DGN576DNC-D feature a classic charcoal grill design it also works as a charcoal smoker.
Anyone familiar with the basic principles of smoking will know that a great smoker needs to have an indirect source of heat. Since this is not possible with a regular charcoal grill the Dyna-Glo DGN576DNC-D features to areas for you to load charcoal. One is up close to the cooking grates so it can function as a charcoal grill. The other is located much lower so it can function as a charcoal smoker.
A very impressive 816 square inches of cooking space makes the Dyna-Glo DGN576DNC-D a giant among our picks of best charcoal smokers. That works out more than enough to cook more than 24 hamburgers at once.
The cooking grates are made from enamelled cast iron. This makes them ideal for heat transfer and provides a steady and even temperature for cooking. These cooking grates are simply excellent for retain heat for searing food which locks in the natural flavor and juices.
A temperature gauge fitted to the hood of the Dyna-Glo DGN576DNC-D makes checking the temperature very simple while an easy to operate and adjustable flue makes heat control a simple affair.
A front door system fitted to the Dyna-Glo DGN576DNC-D makes it very easy to add extra charcoal while a special crank adjusts the charcoal trays. This helps when you are attempting to set the heat of the Dyna-Glo DGN576DNC-D.
Either end of the Dyna-Glo DGN576DNC-D is fitted with two small table like sections which are ideal for placing your utensils or plates of food as you cook.
It is also nice to see that the Dyna-Glo DGN576DNC-D comes with 8 inch resin wheels which make this grill / smoker easy to move around.
If you happen to need a new charcoal grill and wish to buy a charcoal smoker then the Dyna-Glo DGN576DNC-D really could be the best charcoal smoker for you.
|Grill and Smoker Combo||Temperature Is Difficult To Control|
|Large Cooking Area|
See more Smokers here.